Kerala DPI Report Finds No Religious Agenda in Mayilppeeli Young Scholar Exam
A report submitted by the Kerala Directorate of Public Instruction (DPI) to Education Minister Adv. N. Samsudheen has found no religious or political agenda behind the ‘Mayilppeeli Young Scholar Exam’. The inquiry report, submitted on November 18, concluded that there was no deliberate lapse in approving the examination and noted that granting permission to a teachers’ organisation to conduct a scholarship test is not improper.
The examination was organized jointly by ‘Mayilppeeli’ magazine of Balagokulam and the National Teachers’ Union (NTU), which is the Kerala chapter of the Akhil Bharatiya Rashtriya Shaikshik Mahasangh (ABRSM). The report follows the state government’s decision on November 14 to withdraw permission for the test while it was midway through completion, alongside a demand for an explanation from the DPI regarding the initial approval.
Inquiry Findings and Comparison with Other Examinations
According to the DPI’s findings, inquiries into the matter yielded no evidence of a political or religious agenda. The report pointed out that granting such approvals is a standard practice, with several other organisations receiving similar permissions for educational events.
To support this, the DPI cited several existing approvals, including the Eureka Vijnanolsavam conducted by the Sasthra Sahithya Parishad, the Aksharamuttam organized by the CPM-aligned daily ‘Deshabhimani’, and the CH Mohammed Koya Memorial Pratibha Quiz held by the Kerala School Teachers’ Union, which is affiliated with the Indian Union Muslim League. Following the submission of the DPI report, official action against the Joint Director who originally issued permission for the examination is now considered unlikely.
Legal Challenge and Public Reactions
The government’s withdrawal of permission reportedly followed a complaint by the Students’ Federation of India (SFI), the student wing of the CPM, which characterized the exam as an RSS project. On November 19, the NTU filed a petition in the Kerala High Court challenging the cancellation.
In its petition, the NTU contends that it was not granted a hearing prior to the revocation of approval. The organisation asserts that approximately fifteen other entities hold permissions for similar examinations and that targeting the Mayilppeeli exam constitutes discrimination and a violation of the Right to Equality guaranteed under Articles 14 to 18 of the Constitution.
Following the DPI’s findings, R.V. Babu, president of the Hindu Aikyavedi, called for an apology from the State Education Minister and the state government, alleging that the decision was an attempt to isolate Hindu organisations and nationalistic initiatives.
Ministerial Response
During a press briefing on November 18, Education Minister Adv. N. Samsudheen faced questions regarding the cancellation. While acknowledging that multiple organisations hold approvals for scholarship exams, the minister did not provide detailed reasons when asked about the specific withdrawal of permission for the Mayilppeeli examination, stating only that the background of the publication was known.